September 23, 2026
Can AI Help Solve the Peer-Review Crisis? Here Are its Promises and Pitfalls | Science | AAAS
Scheduled maintenance
September 23, 2026
Can AI Help Solve the Peer-Review Crisis? Here Are its Promises and Pitfalls | Science | AAAS
Elizabeth McMahon
Coming
up,
a
stark
look
at
the
barriers
facing
visa
holders
seeking
their
first
pathology
jobs.
Plus,
how
labs
can
be
smarter
stewards
of
a
costly
and
specialized
test
that
analyzes
abnormal
blood
counts.
This
is
Path
News
Network
Daily
Edition
from
the
College
of
American
Pathologists.
I'm
Elizabeth
McMahon.
It's
Wednesday,
September
23rd.
For
years,
graduates
of
U.S.
medical
schools
who
held
visas
have
said
they
had
more
difficulties
finding
their
first
jobs
than
their
U.S.
citizen
counterparts.
A
recent
survey
of
more
than
400
people
provides
fresh
evidence
of
the
barriers
they
encounter.
Dr. Bronwyn Bryant
They
had
to
spend
more
money
because
they
had
maybe
had
lawyer
fees
around
getting
their
visa
status
taken
care
of.
Elizabeth McMahon
That's
Dr.
Bronwyn
Bryant,
a
member
of
the
CAP
Graduate
Medical
Education
Committee
and
one
of
the
study's
authors.
She
said
that
given
a
persistent
shortage
of
pathologists,
the
data
can
help
employers
better
understand
the
steps
they
can
take
to
hire
qualified
staff.
For
program
directors
prepping
international
residents
and
fellows
for
the
market,
Dr.
Bryant
says
strategizing
may
be
key.
Dr. Bronwyn Bryant
They
are
likely
going
to
need
to
start
a
little
earlier.
And
that
if
they
are
considering
what
specialty
they
should
want
to
go
into,
we
know
that
there
is
some
more
commonality
in
more
frequency
in
seeing
some
of
the
ACGME
accredited
fellowships,
um,
such
as
heme
path
and
cytopathology
among
this
population
of
folks
who
were
able
to
achieve
jobs.
Elizabeth McMahon
Find
the
full
study
in
the
August
issue
of
the
Archives
of
Pathology
and
Laboratory
Medicine.
Last
year,
there
were
more
than
8
million
scientific
paper
submissions,
double
the
amount
just
five
years
earlier.
While
AI
is
driving
the
surge
in
submissions,
the
skyrocketing
load
is
overwhelming
editors
and
delaying
publications.
Can
robots
also
sub
in
as
peer
reviewers?
A
new
article
in
the
journal
Science
explores
whether
AI-assisted
review
can
relieve
the
burden.
Though
AI
has
flaws,
scientific
journals
and
conferences
are
evaluating
its
use.
Quote,
I
think
the
norms
are
shifting,
said
one
deputy
editor
of
NEJMAI,
an
affiliate
of
the
New
England
Journal
of
Medicine.
If
a
patient
has
an
abnormal
blood
count,
labs
turn
to
flow
cytometric
testing,
which
counts
subsets
of
cells
in
the
blood.
It's
a
widely
available
but
costly
test.
It's
also
frequently
misapplied
and
demands
a
high
level
of
expertise.
Knowing
when
and
how
to
apply
this
test
is
important,
says
Dr.
Megan
Nakashima,
a
member
of
the
CAP's
Quality
Practices
Committee.
She's
the
author
of
the
CAP's
testing
module
on
peripheral
blood
flow
cytometry.
Dr. Megan Nakashima
We
have
very
experienced
and
subspecialized
medical
laboratory
scientists
running
these
assays.
And
that's
part
of
why
we
really
want
to
be
stewards
of
this
test,
not
because
we
just
want
to
do
fewer
of
them,
but
we
want
to
reserve
our
capacity
to
do
accurate
and
in-depth
analyses
for
cases
that
really
need
it.
Elizabeth McMahon
The
CAP's
test
ordering
program
provides
examples,
questions,
and
insights
about
the
proper
application
of
the
test.
Dr. Megan Nakashima
And
so
those
are
great
applications
of
the
test.
Elizabeth McMahon
Peripheral
blood
flow
cytometry
is
one
of
more
than
two
dozen
testing
modules
available
for
CAP
customers.
And
finally,
there's
a
lot
going
on
on
the
first
full
day
of
CAP
26
in
Las
Vegas,
but
the
Residents
Forum
is
the
place
to
be
for
trainees.
Dr.
Cullen
Lilley
is
chair
of
the
Residents
Forum
Executive
Committee.
He
says
the
October
3rd
meeting
will
center
on
habits
trainees
should
develop
to
set
themselves
up
for
job
success.
Dr. Cullen Lilley
Our
theme
is
measure,
reflect,
improve.
And
so
we're
trying
to
find
those
things
that
you
can
reflect
on
and
say,
you
know,
these
are
areas
that
I
want
to
improve
on.
How
do
you
make
those
goals?
How
do
you
measure
your
success?
Elizabeth McMahon
The
day-long
event
will
include
a
luncheon
with
CAP
House
of
Delegates
members.
That's
all
for
today's
Daily
Edition.
Be
sure
to
check
the
show
notes
for
more
information
on
today's
stories.
Got
a
story
you'd
like
to
hear
on
the
Daily
Edition?
Write
to
us
at
stories
at
Cap.org.
We're
back
at
5
a.m.
Eastern
for
another
episode
of
the
Daily
Edition.
I'm
Elizabeth
McMahon.
Have
a
great
day.